Supreme Court Ruling Reaffirms Power of Federal Regulators
The Supreme Court today narrowly decided to uphold, with significant limits, a doctrine that has plagued the regulated community for years. The case, Kisor v. Wilkie, addressed the issue of whether courts should defer to an agency’s interpretation of its own regulations, known also as Auer deference.
NAHB supported the petitioner with amicus briefs on behalf of an industry coalition organized by the association. NAHB has long been concerned with this type of judicial deference because it can create incentives for agencies to avoid formal rulemaking processes, or create vague regulations that they can interpret and re-interpret at a later date. Either tactic prevents the regulated community from participating in the development of the rules that govern their activities.
Auer deference has harmed NAHB’s interest in a number of cases, including a Clean Water Act case where the court relied on Auer to affirm the finding of a violation against property owners who had constructed a ditch to build a residential subdivision.
In a fractured opinion written by Justice Elena Kagan, the Supreme Court declined to overrule its precedent establishing this deference doctrine, and instead identified a series of factors that courts should use when determining whether Auer deference is appropriate. The court stressed that, under this new formulation, the situations where Auer will be applied will be far fewer than is currently the case.
It remains to be seen whether the limitations recommended by the court will address the many problems that NAHB and others in the regulated community have raised.NAHB will vigilantly monitor the application of this re-imagined Auer deference in the lower courts, and engage in opportunities to ensure that the newly-outlined limitations are broadly applied.
Latest from NAHBNow
Sustainability and Green Building
Aug 28, 2026
NGBS: An Alternative Energy Code Compliance Option
As energy efficiency mandates are becoming more difficult and costly to meet, the National Green Building Standard (NGBS) is emerging as an attractive alternative. Alternative code compliance options - like NGBS Green - are beneficial to local jurisdictions and builders alike, as they provide compliance flexibility without compromising energy performance, and can streamline permitting processes and timelines.
Membership Recruitment and Retention
Aug 27, 2026
Fall Recruitment Competition Set to Begin Sept. 1
Builder and Associate members will work to recruit as many new members as they can by Nov. 30. Winners can earn prizes including LG laundry products and 2027 International Builders' Show perks.
Latest Economic News
Economics
Aug 28, 2026
Multifamily Absorption Rate Remains Below 50%
The percentage of new apartment units that were absorbed within three months after completion was down five percentage points in the first quarter, according to the Census Bureau’s latest release of the Survey of Market Absorption of New Multifamily Units (SOMA).
Economics
Aug 27, 2026
Small Decline for Single-Family Home Size
New single-family home size had been falling since 2015 in response to declining affordability conditions. An exception occurred in 2021, when new home size increased as interest rates reached historic lows.
Economics
Aug 26, 2026
PCE Inflation Remains Sticky
The latest report shows the Federal Reserve’s preferred inflation gauge remains sticky in July, complicating the Fed’s path to its long-term 2% target. Meanwhile, consumer spending remains resilient but is showing signs of slowing, with real consumer spending unchanged in July. Households are pulling back on spending amid persistent inflation.