Supreme Court Hears Arguments in Landmark Impact Fees Case

Legal
Published
Contact: Thomas Ward
[email protected]
VP, Legal Advocacy
(202) 266-8230

The U.S. Supreme Court heard arguments Tuesday in a case brought by a California home owner regarding a $23,000 traffic impact fee required to put a manufactured home on a small parcel of land. The case directly addresses jurisdictions trying to skirt the Takings Clause when seeking impact fees.

The case, Sheetz v. El Dorado County, involved George Sheetz, a California resident who in 2016 applied for a permit to build an 1,800-square-foot manufactured home on a residential-zoned lot he owned. The county imposed a $23,420 “traffic mitigation fee” on the permit. Sheetz protested the fee but ultimately paid it, and then immediately sued the county arguing the fee was improper.

At state court, Sheetz argued that the fee was not closely connected to or proportional to the actual impact his new residence would have on the roads, key tests laid out by precedent in two prior Supreme Court cases (commonly called the Nollan/Dolan test). The county countered that the test does not apply because the impact fee was authorized by legislation — from the county council in this case — rather than by bureaucracy.

A small number of state courts, including California’s, have carved out legal exceptions to the proportionality test if the fees in question are authorized by a legislative body. The Sheetz case directly addresses the constitutionality of such carve outs.

California state courts agreed with the county in this case, writing that the Nollan/Dolan test only applies to fees imposed on an individual basis, rather than fees — such as the traffic impact mitigation fee — authorized by legislation.

Sheetz further appealed the decision to the Supreme Court, noting there was disagreement on the question across states. NAHB and the California Building Industry Association (CBIA) supported Sheetz with an amicus brief urging the Supreme Court to take the case. After the Court agreed to hear it, NAHB and CBIA submitted a second brief supporting Sheetz on the merits of the case.

At oral arguments Tuesday, the justices — and even defendant’s council — seemed to agree with NAHB and CBIA on the pertinent question of legislative action shielding a government from the Takings Clause. NAHB and CBIA wrote that the Supreme Court has an opportunity to “make clear that there is no such ‘loophole’ in the prohibition against governmental demands for unconstitutional conditions.”

Justice Gorsuch noted that with such uniform agreement on the question, the case should simply be remanded to the lower courts so they can determine if the traffic fee falls under the Takings Clause.

An opinion is expected this spring. NAHB VP of Legal Advocacy Tom Ward also discusses the case and the Supreme Court arguments in the latest episode of NAHB’s podcast, Housing Developments.

Subscribe to NAHBNow

Log in or create account to subscribe to notifications of new posts.

Log in to subscribe

Latest from NAHBNow

Advocacy
Nov 17, 2026
Midterm Election Recap: Access Members-Only Webinar

On Nov. 9, NAHB hosted a members-only webinar, “What the Midterm Elections Mean for Housing,” to delve into the results of the midterm elections, key ballot measures and what to expect in the new Congress. NAHB members and HBA staff can access a replay of the webinar on nahb.org.

Economics
Nov 17, 2026
Builder Sentiment Continues to Fall on Affordability Concerns

Builder confidence in the market for newly built single-family homes fell four points to 25 in November, according to the NAHB/Wells Fargo Housing Market Index (HMI) released today. The reading was the lowest since April 2012.

View all

Latest Economic News

Economics
Nov 17, 2026
Custom Home Building Share Rises in 2025

Custom homes accounted for 19.6 % of all single-family homes started in 2025 up from the 17.5 % in 2024. The custom home market consists of contractor-built and owner-built houses—homes built one at a time for owner occupancy on the owner’s land, with either the owner or a builder acting as a general contractor.

Economics
Nov 17, 2026
Builder Sentiment Continues to Fall on Affordability Concerns

Builder confidence has dropped to a 14-year low, dragged down by high mortgage rates, ongoing inflation pressure, elevated energy and material costs, rising labor shortages and hesitant buyers.

Economics
Nov 16, 2026
Single-Family Permitting Weakens While Multifamily Activity Remains Stronger

Residential permitting activity continued to show divergent trends across the single-family and multifamily sectors through September 2026. Single-family permitting remained under pressure, with year-to-date activity declining from a year earlier amid ongoing housing affordability challenges and elevated construction costs.