Corps Announces Efforts to Repeal Use of Appendix C Under Clean Water Act Permits

Environmental Issues
Published

On Feb. 9, 2024, the Army Corps of Engineers (Corps) announced a proposed rule in the Federal Register to repeal existing regulations the agency relies upon (Appendix C) to evaluate, screen and mitigate potential impacts to historic properties and tribal/cultural resources during the Clean Water Act (CWA) Section 404 wetland permitting process.

The National Historic Preservation Act (NHPA) requires all federal agencies to consider the effects on historic properties resulting from federal actions, permits, approvals, funds or assistance. In addition, President Biden has enacted several executive orders and presidential directives focused on increasing the influence and involvement of tribes during the federal permitting process. According to the Biden administration, tribes have long complained the Corps’ Appendix C does not comply with existing regulations under the NHPA and must be withdrawn.

When builders request a CWA Section 404 permit — a dredge-and-fill permit — NHPA Section 106 requirements are triggered to protect historic or cultural significant properties. Under the Corps’ Appendix C procedures, when a builder seeks an individual permit under CWA Section 404, a public notice seeking input on potential impacts to historic/cultural resources is provided to:

  • State Historic Preservation Officer,
  • Appropriate state agencies,
  • Appropriate tribes or tribal representatives,
  • Native Hawaiian organizations,
  • Concerned federal agencies,
  • Appropriate city and county officials, and
  • Interested public.

The Corps acknowledges it only issues approximately 3,000 individual permits annually. By comparison, approximately 35,000 nationwide wetlands permits (NWPs) are issued annually. The Appendix C process for screening NWPs is for district staff to perform the required screening during the NWP’s required preconstruction notification (PCN) process.

Under NHPA Section 106, federal agencies must submit their regulations and processes for screening impacts of their activities upon historic or cultural resources to the Advisory Council on Historic Preservation (ACHP) for “consultation.” The Corps’ current procedures (i.e., Appendix C) to comply with NHPA’s Section 106 were finalized back in 1990 but did not go through the required consultation with the ACHP, as required under the NHPA. However, Appendix C does include important procedural deadlines and clarifications on the scope of the Corps’ review of procedures for:

  • Potential certain coordination,
  • Assessing effects on historic properties, and
  • Providing the ACHP the opportunity to review and comment on undertakings that require Corps permits.

With Appendix C removed, the Corps will need to perform additional rulemaking to comply with NHPA’s Section 106 implementing regulations at 36 CFR 800, including its requirements regarding consultation with tribes and Native Hawaiian organizations.

Public comments must be submitted by April 9, 2024. 

Subscribe to NAHBNow

Log in or create account to subscribe to notifications of new posts.

Log in to subscribe

Latest from NAHBNow

Spring Leadership Meeting

Apr 25, 2025

Virtual Subcommittee Schedule Available for 2025 Spring Leadership Meeting

NAHB’s Spring Leadership Meeting will be held in person from June 10-13 in Washington, D.C. Prior to this year’s meeting, subcommittee meetings will be held virtually beginning the week of May 5.

IBS

Apr 25, 2025

Builder of IBS 2025 Show Home to Share Insights in Live Webinar

Dan Coletti, owner of Sun West Custom Homes and the designer of the 2025 show home, will delve deeper into the design concepts and innovative techniques that defined The New American Home 2025.

View all

Latest Economic News

Economics

Apr 23, 2025

New Home Sales Rise in March

A modest decline in mortgage rates and lean existing inventory helped boost new home sales in March even as builders and consumers contend with uncertain market conditions.

Economics

Apr 22, 2025

The Power of Women in the Workforce

Over the past 125 years, women have played a crucial and multifaceted role in the labor force. Increasing women’s participation in the workforce is not only essential for individual and family well-being, but also contributes significantly to overall labor force participation rates and economic growth by adding more workers and enhancing overall productivity.

Economics

Apr 21, 2025

Who Influences the Purchasing of Building Products?

In a previous post, NAHB analyzed where builders and remodelers purchased products, regardless of who ultimately purchases them (themselves or subcontractors). In this post, the question shifts to who is most often responsible for the choice of particular products.